Which Creepypasta?

Which Creepypasta?

BEN BEN
16.3%
34 votes
SlenderMan SlenderMan
10.5%
22 votes
Smile dog Smile dog
4.8%
10 votes
Jeff the killer Jeff the killer
31.1%
65 votes
Red Red
1%
2 votes
SCP-173 SCP-173
1%
2 votes
Other (Please specify in comments) Other (Please specify in comments)
35.4%
74 votes
Add this poll to your starred list!
▼Scroll down for more polls

Comments (66)

BlueTheQuizWhiz97
Bloody painter
reply
Report
on August 19, 2021
QueLovesTobyandJeff
Report
on January 01, 2021
justyouraveragecreepypastafan
all of them are amazing UwU
reply
Report
on December 11, 2020
DutchesPrecious
Laughing jack, Toby, Jeff, masky etc
reply
Report
on November 19, 2020
official_simp_for_Todoroki
Report
on October 02, 2020
Lil_Phoenix
Tobyyy
reply
Report
on September 03, 2020
Creepypasta_void
Report
on April 26, 2020
chychyphone
Eyeless jack
reply
Report
on April 24, 2020
your.local.patrona
Report
on April 04, 2020
creepypastagrlyo
Clockwork
reply
Report
on April 04, 2020
Hoodie886
I like all creepypastas, except for Clockwork...
reply
Report
on October 03, 2019
Lindsflea
Eyeless Jack
reply
Report
on June 30, 2019
emocreepypastaqueen
homicidal liu
reply
Report
on December 30, 2018
briannacullencc23
puppeteer
reply
Report
on December 16, 2018
daydream99
ticci toby
reply
Report
on October 25, 2018
tatershell
Ticci Toby
reply
Report
on August 22, 2018
Rogue_Red
Masky and Ticci- Toby
reply
Report
on May 16, 2018
Hoodie1
Hoodie
reply
Report
on April 03, 2018
Gamergirlpro
BEN Drowned. Does ANYONE else agree with me? :-O
reply
MOON_Glitch
I agree ✌
reply
Report
on November 28, 2019
AzzlynTheKiller
im sorry no. ticci is best boi
reply
Report
on September 15, 2018
Report
on September 14, 2017
LizzTheKiller
Homicidal liu
reply
Report
on July 25, 2017
OneWeekAtKeishas
Report
on December 23, 2016
deathdawnjenkins
me it have to be lost siver i just think he cool:D
reply
Report
on November 19, 2016
Phantasm
Herobrine
HERObrine
HE HAS HERO IN HIS NAME
reply
Report
on September 02, 2016
Some_dead_golden_flowers
slender man hes ok but idk
reply
Report
on June 20, 2016
steveo8996
ben he prelly cool
reply
Report
on April 25, 2016
roblox
sally:D
reply
Report
on April 16, 2016
ChocolerryPOP
Grinny the cat
reply
Report
on April 14, 2016
Cloudedstar
EJ, Ben Lj and like 600million more
reply
Report
on April 07, 2016
All_hail_Melon_King
Other:EJ! I like Ben too.
reply
Report
on April 07, 2016
annagibbs2003
Eyeless Jack:pB)
reply
Report
on April 02, 2016