who's your favorite creepypasta?

who's your favorite creepypasta?

Lexi: Ok. My faved is BEN. Which is yours of this list. :) BEN: MINE IS.... me. Um. Just Subscribe and comment, NOT ABOUT WHAT I SAID THOUGH!! >:(

Add this question to your starred list!
▼Scroll down for more questions

Answers (84)

vote up or down the answers
3
Frostgoddess
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
on January 30, 2015
Report
2
freshjuicymemes
i like SCP
on July 12, 2020
Report
2
T0od1es
I like Candle Cove, and Pen pal is pretty good too. I don't really like any of the big character ones, I think they're poorly written, nonsensical, and boring (By that I mean Clockwork, Jeff, Ticci Toby, etc. I don't have a problem with Ben drowned though).
on July 06, 2020
Report
2
that.creepy.kid
ALL OF THEM
on July 03, 2020
Report
2
transformers
The Puppeteer
on May 03, 2016
Report
2
Kjepic
My favorites are Smile and Jeff the killer! They have awesome smiles
on May 02, 2016
Report
2
TwistedGrim_EMI
Ticci Toby
on September 02, 2015
Report
2
Noescaping
Eyeless Jack is cool I think Jeff is over-rated (please don't hate me Jeff the Killer fans I still think he's awesome)
on August 01, 2015
Report
2
LexiCha
Jeff: Yah. If you don't vote for me I'll kill you tonight. GO TO SLEEP!!
All_hail_Melon_King
Ok I'll vote for you. I felt bad in the story.
reply
on April 14, 2016
Report
LexiCha
Jeff: amazing choice considering you now have a better chance of staying awake and not going to slee-
Lexi: JEFF!! >:/
reply
on June 19, 2013
Report
LexiCha
2 votes for Jeff!!
Jeff: So can I kill everyone who didn't vote for me?
Lexi: O_o
reply
on April 20, 2013
Report
LexiCha
YEP!! Why does no one ever seem to notice Jack?
reply
on February 07, 2013
Report
BlueStripedFox
Jeff and smiledog
reply
on February 07, 2013
Report
ucmesean
Jeffy is so epic, the series as a whole is brillant :)
reply
on February 05, 2013
Report
on February 05, 2013
Report
2
LexiCha
Ben: ME!!! IF YOU CHOOSE ME YOU CHOOSE VIDEO GAMES AND AWSOMENESS!!
All_hail_Melon_King
I'll vote for you! I love video games!
reply
on April 14, 2016
Report
thatsssanicequizzzyouhavethere
I do I love the zelda games
reply
on May 01, 2013
Report
LexiCha
1 vote for Ben...
Ben: >:o NO ONE LIKES VIDEO GAMES AND AWSOMENESS?!?!
reply
on April 20, 2013
Report
LexiCha
Nevermind I readin' Creepypasta wiki.
reply
on February 07, 2013
Report
LexiCha
Ballet, I wants to talk on the Creepypastas member page with u
reply
on February 07, 2013
Report
LexiCha
:( POOR BEN!!
reply
on February 07, 2013
Report
BlueStripedFox
ooh yeah, but sorry no I wanna be wild and hunt at niht like smiledog
reply
on February 07, 2013
Report
LexiCha
Again I love Ben. He's awsome. :)
reply
on February 05, 2013
Report
on February 05, 2013
Report
1
Monsterwoods
i like a lot of them. masky hoodie ticci toby eyeless jack
on September 07, 2020
Report
1
GreekMythMaker
BEN DROWNED and Slenderman
on September 07, 2020
Report
1
kittyclube64
BENπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’šπŸ’š
on August 22, 2020
Report
1
AishiAyano
on July 07, 2020
Report
1
Hillo
Why is no one pointing out that BEN is gay for himself? :P (I know that's not what it meant but....)
on July 03, 2020
Report
1
RosaAnimeGal37
Oh and slenderman
on November 17, 2018
Report
1
RosaAnimeGal37
Ben Drowned journeyman or jeff
on November 17, 2018
Report
1
ThreeBirds
Not exactly "who", but my favorite creepypasta is the Russian Sleep Experiment. I thought that one was really interesting!
on November 06, 2017
Report
1
OneWeekAtKeishas
EJ IS BAE NO ONE CAN TAKE HIM AWAY~
Undertale_fangirl400
NUUUUUU HE IS MEH BAE!!!!!!!!!!!!
reply
OneWeekAtKeishas
I used a rhyme. you know what? this isn't worth my...
thyme!
(runs)
YOUR WELCOME FOR THE /SPICY/ PUN!!!
lel god have mercy on me
reply
on November 19, 2016
Report
on November 19, 2016
Report
on November 19, 2016
Report
1
Undertale_fangirl400
EYELESS JACK!!!!!!!!!!
on November 18, 2016
Report
1
jacks_scars
well i choose ben because he is my best friend
on September 01, 2016
Report
1
LoneSoul
EJ AND BEN AND TICCI TOBY
on May 03, 2016
Report
1
Neeneepapa_Otaku
I have a list but
1. MASKY
2. Ben
3. Hoddie
4. TOBY!
on May 03, 2016
Report
1
All_hail_Melon_King
Hmm Smile dog, EJ, Masky and hoodie, Ticci LJ,and Jeff. And smile! Selfie! And Ben!-pants- Yeah! I guess it's one vote for EJ=one kidney for him.
All_hail_Melon_King
-spreads creepypasta's food heroicly-
reply
on April 14, 2016
Report
on April 14, 2016
Report
1
Mysterious_Wolf
toby! hes mine -hisses- my toby!
Crystal_Drowned
really? -_-" *Fan girls alert!*
reply
on December 15, 2020
Report
Lil_Phoenix
Sorry hes my bae so back off *growls loudly*
reply
on September 03, 2020
Report
All_hail_Melon_King
No mine!-growls-
reply
Lil_Phoenix
Sorry hes my bae so back off *growls louder*
reply
on September 03, 2020
Report
on April 14, 2016
Report
on September 06, 2015
Report
1
Lunacrafted
FICK FICK FICK this is hard:(.I guess it would be Jeff The Killer or The Cat HunterB)
on February 03, 2015
Report
1
NeonTiger
BEN because it is based off Majora's mask and i love Legend of Zelda. Plus the story is told in a clever way with the statue following him. :)
Crystal_Drowned
thats my bro and that is so cool!
reply
on December 15, 2020
Report
on January 29, 2015
Report
1
gothicskittlescupcake
Mine is jeff.but im not like one of those crazy fangirls.
on December 11, 2014
Report
1
jaguar99
Sexual offenderman aka smexy
EyelessIngrid
on January 29, 2015
Report
on June 21, 2014
Report
1
moonlightkiss
ben because we have things in commen
on April 05, 2014
Report