who's your favorite creepypasta?

who's your favorite creepypasta?

Lexi: Ok. My faved is BEN. Which is yours of this list. BEN: MINE IS.... me. Um. Just Subscribe and comment, NOT ABOUT WHAT I SAID THOUGH!! >

Add this question to your starred list!
▼Scroll down for more questions

Answers (62)

vote up or down the answers
3
LexiCha
Jeff: Yah. If you don't vote for me I'll kill you tonight. GO TO SLEEP!!
Mataways
Ok I'll vote for you. I felt bad in the story.
reply
on April 14
Report
LexiCha
Jeff: amazing choice considering you now have a better chance of staying awake and not going to slee-
Lexi: JEFF!! >:/
reply
on June 19, 2013
Report
LexiCha
2 votes for Jeff!!
Jeff: So can I kill everyone who didn't vote for me?
Lexi: O_o
reply
on April 20, 2013
Report
LexiCha
YEP!! Why does no one ever seem to notice Jack?
reply
on February 07, 2013
Report
BlueStripedFox
Jeff and smiledog
reply
on February 07, 2013
Report
ucmesean
Jeffy is so epic, the series as a whole is brillant
reply
on February 05, 2013
Report
on February 05, 2013
Report
2
TwistedGrim_EMI
Ticci Toby
on September 02, 2015
Report
2
Frostgoddess
BBBBBBBBBBBBBBEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEENNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
on January 30, 2015
Report
2
LexiCha
Ben: ME!!! IF YOU CHOOSE ME YOU CHOOSE VIDEO GAMES AND AWSOMENESS!!
Mataways
I'll vote for you! I love video games!
reply
on April 14
Report
thatsssanicequizzzyouhavethere
I do I love the zelda games
reply
on May 01, 2013
Report
LexiCha
1 vote for Ben...
Ben: >:o NO ONE LIKES VIDEO GAMES AND AWSOMENESS?!?!
reply
on April 20, 2013
Report
LexiCha
Nevermind I readin' Creepypasta wiki.
reply
on February 07, 2013
Report
LexiCha
Ballet, I wants to talk on the Creepypastas member page with u
reply
on February 07, 2013
Report
LexiCha
POOR BEN!!
reply
on February 07, 2013
Report
BlueStripedFox
ooh yeah, but sorry no I wanna be wild and hunt at niht like smiledog
reply
on February 07, 2013
Report
LexiCha
Again I love Ben. He's awsome.
reply
on February 05, 2013
Report
on February 05, 2013
Report
1
Rebel_Fandom_Princess
toby! hes mine -hisses- my toby!
Mataways
No mine!-growls-
reply
on April 14
Report
on September 06, 2015
Report
1
Alexishedgebat
Eyeless Jack is cool I think Jeff is over-rated (please don't hate me Jeff the Killer fans I still think he's awesome)
on August 01, 2015
Report
1
LunerEclipse
BEN BEN BEN ben ben ben ben ben ben ben ben ebne ewbene ebe3 4ebene ene en srry I wuz tipping so fats imean fast
on February 21, 2015
Report
1
Milea
BEN xD I don't know why... ._.
on January 29, 2015
Report
1
NeonTiger
BEN because it is based off Majora's mask and i love Legend of Zelda. Plus the story is told in a clever way with the statue following him.
on January 29, 2015
Report
1
jaguar99
Sexual offenderman aka smexy
EyelessIngrid
on January 29, 2015
Report
on June 21, 2014
Report
1
moonlightkiss
ben because we have things in commen
on April 05, 2014
Report
1
LexiCha
Laughing Jack: VOTE FOR ME and maybe I won't fill your guts with candy VoTe FoR Me! VoTe FoR Me! C:<
Mataways
I only vote for creepypastas that are awesome!
reply
Mataways
LJ earns a vote!-because he laughs right? He's also funny!-
reply
on April 14
Report
on April 14
Report
jexix200
I vote for you!
reply
on July 18, 2014
Report
LexiCha
LJ: *laughs evily and smiles at Owl* I'll do the best I can. Hehe, and I'll try to make it painfull yet fast just for you. *smiles evily*
reply
on July 12, 2013
Report
LexiCha
LJ: Bye bye dear Owl I will make sure to say "Hi" to Mary_Chan. Mwahaha.
Lexi: 0_0 This is gonna end badly...
reply
on July 11, 2013
Report
LexiCha
LJ: Well, well, well. Isn't that just perfect. Mwahaha. Thankyou for the information, Owl.
Lexi: Uh-oh..
reply
on July 10, 2013
Report
LexiCha
LJ: Me? Or Lexi
Lexi: Me?
reply
on July 10, 2013
Report
LexiCha
Lexi: ? Where did you come from LJ? 0_o
LJ: I followed Masky and Hoodie
reply
on July 09, 2013
Report
on July 09, 2013
Report
1
LoveBlade
EYELESS JACK!
Mataways
No my EJ!
reply
on April 14
Report
LexiCha
I hope you enjoy it, too!!
reply
on May 16, 2013
Report
LexiCha
Lexi: JACK'S GOT ANOTHER FAN!! P.s you should read my Creepypastas Conversation Show... more like a talk show but whateva. I think you should because I did 2 Creepypasta Vote things and guess what.... JACK WON BOTH!! XD
reply
on May 16, 2013
Report
on May 16, 2013
Report
1
thatsssanicequizzzyouhavethere
Can I vote for everyone? Cuz I love all of them really so I can't pick a favorite
LexiCha
Lolz!! It alright 'cause in the show (I HAVE A CREEPYPASTA SHOW X3) we already counted the votes and etc.
reply
on April 26, 2013
Report
on April 25, 2013
Report
1
thatsssanicequizzzyouhavethere
I pick Jack. Sorry Smile Dog I didn't pick you but you are still amazing
LexiCha
Lexi: JACK!!!
Jack: :'( I'm sorry....
Lexi: It's fine. I got you a kidney though.
Jack: Yay!
reply
on April 20, 2013
Report
LexiCha
Jack: Thank you.....
I shouldn't ask for anything from a voter buuuuut *stomach growls* O_o
reply
on April 20, 2013
Report
on March 21, 2013
Report
1
thatsssanicequizzzyouhavethere
Or jack... Smile Dog or Jack? I CAN'T CHOOSE
on March 20, 2013
Report
1
thatsssanicequizzzyouhavethere
on March 19, 2013
Report
1
LexiCha
Eyeless Jack: Hey..... go me... hehe. *blushes*
LexiCha
Jack: ......
reply
on April 20, 2013
Report
LexiCha
3 votes for Jack!!
reply
on April 20, 2013
Report
thatsssanicequizzzyouhavethere
on March 23, 2013
Report
LexiCha
Thnks Bing. He is a cute cannibal!! :b Lol!!
reply
on February 13, 2013
Report
Bing00
I have to vote for Jack because compared to the other creepypastas, he dosen't sound like that much of a killer and he's not as adnormal as the others, plus, he seems pretty cool to me. =)
reply
on February 12, 2013
Report
LexiCha
Hmmm... I think I'll also vote you for being a cute cannibal.
reply
on February 05, 2013
Report
on February 05, 2013
Report
0
Undertale_fangirl400
HUE HUE HUE FUNNY!
14 days ago
Report
0
OneWeekAtKeishas
EJ IS BAE NO ONE CAN TAKE HIM AWAY~
Undertale_fangirl400
NUUUUUU HE IS MEH BAE!!!!!!!!!!!!
reply
OneWeekAtKeishas
I used a rhyme. you know what? this isn't worth my...
thyme!
(runs)
YOUR WELCOME FOR THE /SPICY/ PUN!!!
lel god have mercy on me
reply
14 days ago
Report
14 days ago
Report
14 days ago
Report
0
Undertale_fangirl400
EYELESS JACK!!!!!!!!!!
15 days ago
Report
0
jacks_scars
well i choose ben because he is my best friend
on September 01
Report
0
LoneSoul
EJ AND BEN AND TICCI TOBY
on May 03
Report
0
Crazy_Amine_lover_Rper
I have a list but
1. MASKY
2. Ben
3. Hoddie
4. TOBY!
on May 03
Report
0
TricksterOfLife
The Puppeteer
on May 03
Report
0
Kjepic
My favorites are Smile and Jeff the killer! They have awesome smiles
on May 02
Report
0
Mataways
Hmm Smile dog, EJ, Masky and hoodie, Ticci LJ,and Jeff. And smile! Selfie! And Ben!-pants- Yeah! I guess it's one vote for EJ=one kidney for him.
Mataways
-spreads creepypasta's food heroicly-
reply
on April 14
Report
on April 14
Report
0
Rebel_Assasin
Masky or EJ.
I love the proxies! Idk why x3
on December 18, 2015
Report
0
indigozap
ticci toby
on December 03, 2015
Report
0
Animgame
entity.303
on September 04, 2015
Report