Lapis_Lazuli Investigates: Steven Universe Theories

The Sardonyx Theory

What is it?: The Sardonyx Theory states that Jasper is like the "Cluster" (Gem shards stuck together) and that Sardonyx is a part of her.
Right now, do I believe that this is true?: Hm, maybe...
Evidence of this theory being true: Jasper`s Gem has three separate faces that look like they could be Gem shards. Some believe that she was a successful "Cluster". She also has two colors on her skin that aren`t neatly put together.
Evidence of this theory being false: If Jasper was a successful "Cluster", then why couldn`t HomeWorld do it again? Plus, she says in Jailbreak, "You only beat me because you`re a fusion." That says she cannot be a fusion unless she never knew she was a fusion of other Gem shards. Even if that isn`t enough, in Pearl`s hologram of the battle with Rose Quartz in "Sworn to the Sword" a Jasper-like figure can be seen with an axe, about to squish Rose.
Do I believe this theory to be true?: No, not anymore. The weight of the evidence saying this theory is not true clearly overpowers the theory being true, so thus I say this theory cannot be possibly true, unless we get more information on Jasper.