What was your first reaction to..Creepy pasta?

What was the first ever creepy pasta story you ever read whether it was Jeff the killer, smiledog or even cupcakes(from mlp FiM). Post in the comments also don't forget to post your reaction.Did not know what to classify it as so yeah..

Be the first to add this question to starred list!
▼Scroll down for more questions

Answers (9)

vote up or down the answers
1
tamha
My first one was probally buried alive (Pokemon Creepy Pasta) but the first real one I heard is the Russain Sleep Experiment. My favorite is Creepy Black (another pokemon one) , but my favorite "real" one is by far Ben Drowned
The_Panda_Otaku
Actually.The other ones are creepy pastas too,Just Ben drowned is probably one of the more known ones
reply
on April 19, 2014
Report
on April 16, 2014
Report
1
hesitantalien
Mmkaay

'Twas back in the day when I was not familiar with Minecraft. My dear friend Holly told me about a monster called an Enderman. Intrigued, I browsed YouTube for said monster. I observed a video which said that Endermen are based on urban myth Slenderman. I researched Slenderman, and at first I was quite scared. I found that he was something called a creepypasta. I read some stories on creepypasta.com, and now I am quite a fan.


And when I saw Jeff The Killer for the first See More▼
The_Panda_Otaku
on April 04, 2014
Report
Acacia_The_Goddess
OMG Same! XD
reply
on April 03, 2014
Report
on April 03, 2014
Report
0
breann.west.5
When I first saw Jeff- Hm, not so creepy.
I start looking at more pictures- Oh my god, these guys are so cute!
Is there something wrong with me? XD
on October 05, 2015
Report
0
PlzStopFollowingMeThisAccountIsNotInUseThxBby
on July 26, 2014
Report
0
Vanessa_the_dark
dang...it was such a long time ago i can hardly remember! but....unless im wrong i think it was either jane the killer jeff the killer or slenderman though i most think it was jeff the killer and my reaction was "*becomes creepypasta/jeff the killer fangirl* i like this! its soooo cool!"
Vanessa_the_dark
XD ikr
reply
on June 06, 2014
Report
The_Panda_Otaku
Lol Jeffs awesome
reply
on June 06, 2014
Report
on June 06, 2014
Report
0
MockingjayDistrict
At first I had no idea what it was and I was like, Pasta that is creepy? Who comes up with this stuff?!?!?! But judging society today, I wouldn't be surprised if Creepy pasta was literally pasta that was creepy.
MockingjayDistrict
*Goes through portal with you and closes it once with both escape*
reply
on April 27, 2014
Report
The_Panda_Otaku
-starts heading off with the sauce just speeding us up- Oh no! WALL!
-creates portal on the other side of wall and one infront of us so we dont run into the wall-
reply
on April 27, 2014
Report
MockingjayDistrict
Lets go! Move move!
reply
on April 27, 2014
Report
The_Panda_Otaku
-goes back- I got you! -helps her up and we both start running-
I haz idea!
-a black motorbike with red flames along the sides appears along with a helmet in same style, there also is another black motorbike with indigo fire along the sides with matching helmet- Get on the motorbike! -hops on first motorbike and gets prepared to go once shes ready-
reply
on April 27, 2014
Report
MockingjayDistrict
I mean crimson lol
reply
on April 27, 2014
Report
MockingjayDistrict
*Runs after her but slips on stray marinara sauce* HELP CRI SON!
reply
on April 27, 2014
Report
The_Panda_Otaku
-grab a portal gun and creates two portals so i dont drown-
WE NEED TO GET OUT OF HERE!!
-starts running-
reply
on April 27, 2014
Report
MockingjayDistrict
*SCREAMS* To much marinara saaaaaauce
reply
on April 19, 2014
Report
The_Panda_Otaku
AHH!!
IM DROWNING IN A POOL OF BUTTE-*gurgling sounds are heard but then stop*
reply
on April 19, 2014
Report
MockingjayDistrict
Aaaah! It's so buttery
reply
on April 17, 2014
Report
The_Panda_Otaku
Nooo!!!
ANYTHING BUT THAT!!!
reply
on April 17, 2014
Report
MockingjayDistrict
The Rabid Ravioli is coming to GeEeEeEt YoOoOu
reply
on April 14, 2014
Report
The_Panda_Otaku
on April 13, 2014
Report
MockingjayDistrict
OoOOooOOhhHHhhHH!!!! It's the Scary Spaghetti! RUN FOR YOUR LIVES!!!!!!!!!!!
reply
on April 07, 2014
Report
The_Panda_Otaku
Yeah if people had not heard of creepy pasta they probably would think:
'How is pasta creepy?' Or something like that
reply
on April 07, 2014
Report
on April 06, 2014
Report
0
Stars_In_The_Sky
My first one was slenderman and I freaked out then I was like ?.? then I was like *shrug*
The_Panda_Otaku
on April 03, 2014
Report
Stars_In_The_Sky
Well my little brother was behind me the first time I saw one and later I asked if he saw it and he's like what the octopus? lol
reply
on April 03, 2014
Report
The_Panda_Otaku
A.k.a the three stages (or more) of creepy pasta (in a way)
reply
on April 03, 2014
Report
on April 03, 2014
Report
0
Frostgoddess
My first creepypasta(actually reading, not just hearing of it) was Ben.
My reaction: Before I starte reading creepypasta, my little sister was obsessed with it. My first reaction was LAME! But then I started reading it AND IT IS AWESOME!
The_Panda_Otaku
I just read sonic e.x.e since i have not read it dont question me and yeah.
reply
on April 03, 2014
Report
on April 03, 2014
Report
0
The_Panda_Otaku
My first creepy pasta was Jeff.
My reaction: At first i was like O.O wha?
Then it changed to:AHHHH!!
Then:
on April 03, 2014
Report