Does This Sound Strange To You Too? New Story?

There was a math question on one of my tests and it said something like, "Jeff made quilts-" I stopped reading there and the first thought that popped into my head was Jeff The Killer, obviously. I think about him every time I hear the name Jeff just because I know him so well. But that's not what sounds strange. After getting ready for school the next morning, I brought up the topic to my brother. He was like, "Jeff doesn't make quilts."
Me: I know.]
Brother: So why are we talking about it?]
Me: Because it sounds like Slender would be very confused.]
Brother: Everypasta would be.]
Me: Slender would be like, "Where did we go wrong?!"]
Brother: And Ben would say, "Jeff, why are you making quilts?!"]
Me: Jeff says, "I'm not" ;Ben; Yes you are! ;Jeff; I changed Ben, I changed. ;Slender+Ben; Where did we go wrong?! ;Jeff; I don't kill anymore. ;Slender; He's messed up.]
Brother: Then Jeff would take a quilt and throw it over his head like he was hiding and go, "QUILT!"]
We laughed at the thought and kept on going on and on with it. My questions are: Does that sound strange to you like it does to me? and, Should I make it a silly story just for some laughs?