Which Creepypasta Do You Like?

Which Creepypasta Do You Like?

Who do you think is the hottie? GIVE YOUR REASON!
Mine are Masky and Jeff. Masky because he likes Cheesecake, (I wonder what he looks like?). Jeff because I would be curious on how it would go.

Add this question to your starred list!
▼Scroll down for more questions

Answers (10)

vote up or down the answers
1
tatertotz
I like Ticci Toby b/c he's cute, funny, and kind. If I had met him, I would annoy Masky with him.
on August 17, 2018
Report
1
Anonymous_Tnt
Mine is probably Eyeless jack he is really cool!
on December 25, 2016
Report
1
breann.west.5
None of them. Creepypastas aren't supposed to be "hotties". They were intended to be scary, and its fangirls like you who ruin them for me.
WifeOfLaughingJack
Well..... Im one of those fangirls......
reply
Lullaby_Lucy
Yep I'm with you @WifeOfLaughingJack
reply
on November 12, 2018
Report
on November 29, 2016
Report
on November 28, 2016
Report
0
CreepyGamer
I would have to say E.j well because he is so relatable and I just think he would be super shy and friendly and mysterious which I like in a person so yeah and also we could eat kidneys together...IF YOU HAVE TRIED KIDNEY AND LIKED IT YOU ARE ON MY GOOD LIST
on June 27
Report
0
Cameo
.........Jeff the killer is kinda cute....so is Ben drowned.....but idk
on April 25
Report
0
emocreepypastaqueen
LIU TOBY AND MASKY liu bc i mean he's like me toby bc i relate to him and masky bc y not?
on December 27, 2018
Report
0
Lullaby_Lucy
Well I would date Toby because he is just a goof ball and cute and loves waffles!
but I think E.J. would be my crush because He's hot,he is trustworthy,and kind (to some people).
And Jeff would be my best friend because he is a rebel,cool,fun to go on killing sprees with,and likes to mess with the other creepypastas.
on November 12, 2018
Report
0
TheSkysTheLimit
BEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEN
JEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEFF
on April 25, 2017
Report
0
All_hail_Melon_King
First of all, I'm happy to answer.


Due to rough fangirls I'm gonna have to say idk
on December 22, 2016
Report
0
Orange.Soda
*cough, cough*
None. First, they aren't meant to be hot. They aren't scary to me, but they weren't meant to be hot. They were intended to be corrupted, and just a good story to read on Halloween, but not "hot"
Second, even if they were real, they wouldn't be attatched to anyone outside other creepy pastas. Take, for instance, Sweeney Todd. Spoilers, his wife is dead and daughter never comes across him after Todd goes missing. Due to him coming back in the beginning, he's so corrupted, See More▼
WifeOfLaughingJack
If you HAVE to date one, that is......
reply
on November 29, 2016
Report
WifeOfLaughingJack
Who do like, that's all I really mean.....
reply
on November 29, 2016
Report
on November 28, 2016
Report