Who's your favorite CreepyPastas?

Who's your favorite CreepyPastas?

Add this question to your starred list!
▼Scroll down for more questions

Answers (14)

vote up or down the answers
2
gothicskittlescupcake
Jeff,but I'm not a crazy fangirl.
on December 15, 2014
Report
2
Sassy_Mime
on November 06, 2014
Report
1
GirlsDeMo
Cool
Loveable
Officially amazing
Clock eye
Killer
Wonderful
Oh my god awesome! See More▼
on November 15, 2014
Report
1
planetfroot
Smile dog.
on November 14, 2014
Report
1
RaLLiCrossoverH2
Ticci Toby
He's awsome
TicciToby335
I know right?
reply
on November 08, 2014
Report
on November 08, 2014
Report
1
Masubii_Chan
on November 06, 2014
Report
1
FallingRozePetals
Scary
Lerking
Errupting
Nightful
Dreadful
Exellent
Roaring See More▼
on November 06, 2014
Report
1
LunaWolf279
JEFF THE KILLER !!! OR EJ ! OR LJ GAH CAT CHOSE!
on November 06, 2014
Report
0
Library_Guy
Don't Walk The Yellow Brick Road.
on Tuesday
Report
0
Fang_The_Alpha_Wolf
on Tuesday
Report
0
MLPFANCHICK2121
I am gonna say Masky and Jeff, and yes, I'm a crazy fangirl! ^////^
on Monday
Report
0
Lunacrafted
Idk but I do love ticci-Toby and Jeff
on January 23, 2015
Report
0
J.Killa
Like who?...hm....
JEFF THE HOTTY FRICKIN KILLER!! xD
He's so damn hot,sexy,dangerous,aaaaand...
MINE!! hehe
on November 06, 2014
Report
0
TicciToby335
Ticci toby
on November 06, 2014
Report