Scariest Creepypasta

The Rake
36.1%
35 votes
Slenderman
18.6%
18 votes
Jeff The Killer
25.8%
25 votes
BEN
4.1%
4 votes
Eyeless Jack
3.1%
3 votes
SmileDog
12.4%
12 votes
Add this poll to your starred list!
▼Scroll down for more polls

Comments (31)

Bloodthief
The Rake!
(I love you ej) *-*:x
reply
Report
on October 27, 2017
ThreeBirds
I thought a few of these were badly written, and therefore, don't scare me.
reply
Report
on August 27, 2017
SuicideSmileyface
Definitely the rake....and I don't scare easily
reply
Report
on January 18, 2017
Shattered
Rake.... He is just creepy and a bit scary in my opinion... *shivers slightly.*
reply
Report
on June 14, 2016
Orange.Soda
Ok, it's not here, and not a person, but an experiment.
It's more of saddening and sickening.
Russian sleep experiment.
reply
Lightstriker195
This is disturbing, but fair, very fair.... I like the way you think
reply
Report
on January 01, 2016
Report
on December 30, 2015
Stardancer
Smile Dog
reply
Report
on November 13, 2015
Insane_feline
Jeffy isn't really scary, i just like him alot :3
reply
Report
on November 08, 2015
breann.west.5
BEN isn't scary :T
reply
Report
on September 07, 2015
Polixious
The rake is scary.
reply
Report
on March 27, 2015
Lunacrafted
Smile dog is so scary but so cute:x
reply
Report
on February 16, 2015
ZodiacAnimeFreak
Scariest the take and my fave is slenderman
reply
ZodiacAnimeFreak
Report
on July 06, 2014
Report
on July 06, 2014
TossedWhisper4
I was stuck between Slendy and Jeff :-& *shutter* they both scared the hell out of me...Rake too...
reply
Report
on April 23, 2014
Skar.the.Killer
I dont understand how people think Jeff is scary. he's sweet
reply
Report
on April 20, 2014
gonebitches
Smile dog is a bit creepy but its kinda funny. Ben isn't scary at all. The rake... Eh... Slenderman NONONONONO NOT SCARY AT ALL! Jeff The Killer HOLY CRAP FREAKING NIGHTMARES FOR 2 WEEKS NOW
reply
Report
on March 18, 2014
Bluetomatosauce13
smile dog looks like a bloody jeff the killer *shutter*:-&
reply
Report
on February 16, 2014
Josieposie
Rake....he just scares the crap out of me.
reply
Report
on January 25, 2014
Lightstriker195
Lol, I ,love the replies
reply
Report
on January 08, 2014
BasicCactus
I'm gonna have to say the Rake, but Laughing Jack is freaky. 0_0
reply
Report
on January 08, 2014
WOBBLYSHIZ
are u kidding me? jeff da killer creepypasta not scary.. hes kewl dough
reply
Report
on December 24, 2013
Sombra
Smiledog, it is a blood-covered, smiling, creepy German Shepard.
reply
Report
on December 15, 2013
heterophobic
Jeff the Killa
reply
Report
on November 28, 2013
seippup12
Jeff I HAAAAAAAAAAAAAWWWWWWWWWWWTTTTTTTTTTT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!B)
reply
Report
on November 28, 2013
Celest_Stories
Mary-Chan and OneHellOfAButler666 I totally agree with you! I wish was real and we could go on killing sprees together! <3 i have a good knife,,,,,,, lol ~(>///<)~
I also love Black Butler!
reply
Report
on November 19, 2013
Lightstriker195
Report
on November 12, 2013
xxxvanny
The rake freaks me out :((
reply
Report
on November 12, 2013
Lightstriker195
poor BEN
reply
Report
on November 11, 2013
Noodlez013
I agree with OneHellOfAButler666 andMary_Chan he is be-a-u-tiful
reply
Report
on November 10, 2013
OneHellOfAButler666
I agree with Mary_chan.. I want to marry him! <3
reply
Report
on November 09, 2013
Mary_chan
PSH jeff isnt scary he's beautiful >///<
reply
Report
on November 09, 2013