Why does everyone think that the Sonic 2006 game was bad?

Why does everyone think that the Sonic 2006 game was bad?

I have the Sonic 06 game. I haven't played that many Sonic games, but of all the ones I have played, this one was my favorite BY FAR! But Everyone says "Oh, that game was terrible!" "It was just a bunch of wasted potential!" Blah blah blah! I don't get it! I know it's just opinions, but I only see one thing wrong with it and it can be described in one word:
Elise.
That's the only really bad thing about it. I found the game really fun to play, and it had excellent music! Also, THEY INTRODUCED SILVER AND MEPHILES!!! I mean, really! Mephiles is my favorite Sonic villain OF ALL TIME! And of Silver Shadow, and Sonic, I like Silver the most. He's also the best one to play.
Back to the question, how is it such a 'bad' game?

Add this question to your starred list!
▼Scroll down for more questions

Answers (6)

vote up or down the answers
0
Redpandaddaj
They tried re-making a worldwide favored game. You can never relive the same expierience!
Redpandaddaj
No matter how hard you try to remake it, you can't beat the originals, unless it's something like FNAF
reply
on December 06, 2016
Report
on December 06, 2016
Report
0
Megpoid_GUMI
It was awful because SEGA tried so many things in an attempt to give the gamers an unforgettable experience.
But after they did, their deadline to release the game was near, and they didn't have time to erase the glitches and bugs that were created. They introduced at least 10 game modes when all 3 characters you can play with are put together.
In Sonic's story, you have Sonic, Tails, and Knuckles
In Shadow's, you have Shadow, Rouge, and Omega
In Silver's, you have Silver, Blaze, See More▼
Redpandaddaj
I agree all the way
reply
on December 06, 2016
Report
Frostgoddess
Paragraph 1: .... *shrugs* I personally think they did well.
paragraph 2: YEAH! TOTALLY! 8D
paragraph 3: *nods head furiously* I HATE Elise! How many times did she get captured in that game? I lost count.
reply
on September 02, 2014
Report
on September 02, 2014
Report
0
AcousticIdiot
I haven't played it but I saw the cut scenes and I love the way it played out.However, I agree with your thoughts on Elise.
on August 01, 2014
Report
0
AcousticIdiot
I haven't played it but I saw the cut scenes and I love the way it played out.However, I agree with your thoughts on Elise.
on August 01, 2014
Report
0
AcousticIdiot
I haven't played it but I saw the cut scenes and I love the way it played out.However, I agree with your thoughts on Elise.
on August 01, 2014
Report
0
DarkAngel1204
I never played it but I watches the play through and it was awesome! Not my favorite one but I simply loved it!! It was wonderful! It explained a lot and was so graphic! Amazing game
on July 04, 2014
Report