why does everyone think Pinkamena Diane Pie is weird or creepy?
everyone thinks that this pony is scary. Pinkamena is just a misunderstood pony. In my opinion, I think she is more cute with a long mane!
Add this question to your starred list!
▼Scroll down for more questions▼
Answers (10)
vote up or down the answers
Answer Link
Why is there SO much hate do this pony. In my opinion, it's kind of like "Save Derpy". A lot of people hate her and said that she should be taken off the show. She is just a normal pony! I DON'T care what you say about her, She is still my second fav. (because my 1 fav. is Derpy) She is my phone screen saver, believe it or not!
on July 10, 2013
Answer Link
I hate the writers of "Cupcakes". Making sure that an innocent pony get's framed for killing all of ponyville.
on July 10, 2013
Answer Link
I think people think pinkamenas weird and creepy just because of the story Cupcakes but they should no its just a fanfic someone made.Seriously I agree with you because she isn't really that weird and she is quite pretty with her hair down :)
on April 02, 2014
Answer Link
honey i've read the fan fic and the tumblr dubs. she is so not innocent.....but she is pretty cool
on December 10, 2013
Answer Link
Pinkamena Diane Pie is in a Creepypasta called "cupcakes". She kills innocent ponys and uses them in her recepe of cupcakes... Isn't that great! :D Then she feeds them to the other ponies :D
I know the creepypasta "cupcakes". I wish to never read it but I've seen pictures with her and the body parts of the ponies. I have NO idea why the writers would do such a thing with that pony! what if they made "cupcakes" with Derpy or something. Derpy isn't a killer and neither is Pinkamena!
on July 10, 2013
on July 10, 2013