(Biggest Debate) Which is scarier: FNAF of Creepypasta?

(Biggest Debate) Which is scarier: FNAF of Creepypasta?

Five Nights at Freddy's
42.5%
17 votes
Five Nights at Freddy's
Creepypasta
57.5%
23 votes
Creepypasta
Add this poll to your starred list!
▼Scroll down for more polls

Comments (19)

GamesFan78
Creepypasta
reply
Report
on October 06
TwistedGrim_EMI
Creepypasta can scare you shitless with some of its stories but the fandom is...ok
reply
Report
on September 20, 2015
breann.west.5
Honestly, none. FNaF is adorable, and so is CP.(Only BEN is defiantly most kawaii)
reply
Report
on August 08, 2015
WarriorCats555
fnaf isnt really scary, but the backstory is really interesting. but its not scary either :3 im too lazy to type all the backstory
reply
Report
on April 30, 2015
xxredfeatherx
Honestly in the game of fnaf. It's not to bad i mean the jumpscares are alright nothing to write home about. But the lore I amazing and makes it 200 times scarier
reply
Report
on March 07, 2015
FallingRozePetals
Creepypasta. Cause FNAF is not real.but some CreepyPasta's are legends. Thats mean real or not real. And there is a HUDGE bunch of them besides fnaf
reply
Report
on February 08, 2015
Masubii_Chan
I would say Creepypasta in my opinion. FNAF, it's just full of jumpscares and doesn't really have a lasting fear while creepypasta makes me scared for a couple days or weeks.
reply
Report
on February 08, 2015
india1
I'm a girl nether are very scary but I just like creepypastas more the game didn't even make me jump not even once true story u can ask my brother , mom, dad,dead
reply
FallingRozePetals
Your parents r dead? o_O
reply
Report
on February 08, 2015
Report
on December 05, 2014
FNAF_ToyBonnie
if u vote creepypasta you will see just how scary a fnaf jumpscare is soon
reply
Report
on December 04, 2014
Whisker_Queer
FNAF
reply
Report
on November 28, 2014
XxfoxythepiratexX
none of them my friends would get so scared about creepypastas but i was just like man it's not scary then fnaf my friends like so creeped out but its not even scary i mean geez
reply
Report
on November 25, 2014
Lord_Fluffanipps
FNAF.... I've read all the pasta's and none phase me. But I have been having NIGHTMARES about FNAF
reply
Report
on November 24, 2014
GirlsDeMo
Creepypasta obviously!
FNAF scared me for a bit (the first time I saw it ) ..but now I'm like eh
Creepypasta sometimes gives me evil nightmares!
reply
Report
on November 24, 2014
DarkAngel1204
Creepypasta. I mean come on FNAF wasn't even that scary.
reply
AnimeGarden
agreed
reply
Report
on November 23, 2014
Report
on November 23, 2014
Your_Average_Fangirl
Creepypasta because seriously...im so used to wildcards and screamers now a days that I just don't react to them or thin they are scary
reply
Report
on November 23, 2014
Jeweled_Feather
Report
on November 23, 2014
AnimeGarden
Okay i know this is weird but, me and my brother were fighting, which is scarier. I think creepypasta, he thinks FNAF. I wanted to ask the interwebs what they thought. Thanks!
reply
Report
on November 23, 2014