Whose the hottest creepy pasta?

Whose the hottest creepy pasta?

E.J
16.7%
2 votes
Toby
58.3%
7 votes
Bloody painter/Helen Otis
8.3%
1 vote
Dr.Smiley
0%
0 votes
The puppeteer
0%
0 votes
Who are these people and why are they hot?
16.7%
2 votes
Be the first to add this poll to starred list!
▼Scroll down for more polls

Comments (5)

phanpy
mmm, bloodthirsty sociopaths. so sexy.
reply
Report
on July 24, 2018
EyelessEmilyKiller
E j O////O. Mkay I like him soo yea.....
reply
Report
on June 11, 2017
ThreeBirds
Why is this a thing.
reply
Report
on May 29, 2017
All_hail_Melon_King
E J he likes me so yeah.
reply
Report
on March 31, 2016
WarriorBunny
Toby
reply
Report
on December 21, 2015