Should I stick with my current art style or change it to this?

Use both! It's what I did when I switched art styles. :>

Also I may not use this because I may like one more than I thought, because pros cons.
Like Number 1 is I think is too cartoony for me, but easy is to draw and can easier expressions.
Number 2 is that it is Creepy enough for me, like Tim burton, so I like that about it, but it can be hard with body portions

Both is really good and quite similar..!