Best main Creepypasta? Slenderman 15% 3 votes SUGAR0BABY Answer Link Laughing Jack 5% 1 vote SUGAR0BABY Answer Link Ticci Toby 40% 8 votes SUGAR0BABY Answer Link Jeff the Killer 10% 2 votes SUGAR0BABY Answer Link BEN DROWNED (picture of Ben and me) 15% 3 votes SUGAR0BABY Answer Link Eyeless Jack 15% 3 votes SUGAR0BABY Answer Link SUGAR0BABY (Taylor Pennington) published on April 14, 2016 14 polls 7 pages Follow Create a Poll on Qfeast. It's just too easy! Star Poll Be the first to add this poll to starred list! ▼Scroll down for more polls▼ Comments (1) All_hail_Melon_King Toby. Sorry you guys but it has to be this way. 0 0 reply Report on April 24, 2016 Subscribe