How Well Do You Know "American Idol"? If you think you're the ultimate "American Idol" freak, see how much you really know! caandny published on June 18, 201011 responses 1 5.0★ / 5 Questions in vertical order Who was the winner of Season 3? Ruben Studdard Carrie Underwood Fantasia Burrino Dianna DiGarmo Who was the winner of Season 1? Type answer (14 letters) Who are the original 3 judges? Type answer (23 letters) What season did Kara DioGuardi get added on to the judging panel? Type answer (1 letters) (Now it gets hard...) Who was the guest judge in Season 9 on the same episode as Joe Jonas? Select the one correct answers Katy Perry Neil Patrick Harris Victoria Beckham Ellen DeGeneres Who came in third place on Season 4? Type answer (15 letters) When Carly Smithson re-appeared on Idol, she performed with another contestant from the same season as her. Who was he? Type answer (13 letters) Who came in second place Season 2? Type answer (10 letters) One contestant from Season 4 went on to be a star in the play "The Fantastiks" in New York City. Who was that? Select the one correct answers Anthony Federov Scott Savel Nadia Turner Lindsey Cardinale Who did second and third place go to Season 5? Select the one correct answers Taylor Hicks and Katherine McPhee Katherine McPhee and Elliot Yamin Taylor Hicks and Elliot Yamin Elliot Yamin and Chris Daughtry