Which Creepypasta loves you?!

Which Creepypasta loves you?!

Me: (Drags Jeff, Toby, Hoodie, and EJ into the room) Hey everybody I'm here with Hoodie's squad and we're gonna see which one is in love with you! Toby: YAY Jeff: You're wasting my time Me: (Points knife at Jeff) Do this or I'll beat you.

published on July 1325 responses 4
Next »
1/5

Me: Alright who wants to go first?! Toby: I DO Jeff: DON'T YOU DARE SAY- Toby: DO YOU LOVE WAFFLES Everybody accept me: NO

YESSSSSSS!!
NNNOOO
I guess I kind've do
What about Cheesecake
2/5

Me: Alright wh- Jeff: Whats your favorite color and weapon

Red, for blood and KNIFES
Blue and I like surgery tools
Yellow and Guns
Does Waffles count as a color, and axes
3/5

Me: EJ its your turn EJ: Um... Can I- Me: DON'T YOU DARE SAY IT EJ: Fine, What's your favorite food

Steak or anything similar like that
WAFFLES FOREVER BABY
Kidn- I mean pizza, pizza is good
Cheesecake
4/5

Me: Alright Ho- Hoodie: Whats your favorite thing to do Me: STOP INTERRUPTING ME

Killing, killing, killing
Eating waffles and bugging Masky
Eating Cheesecake
Cleaning my surgery supplies
5/5

Me: Finally my turn, alright this won't affect your answers, which is your favorite creepypasta out of these four

Jeff the Killer
Ticci Toby
Eyeless Jack
Hoodie