Who's your favorite CreepyPastas?

Who's your favorite CreepyPastas?

Add this question to your starred list!
▼Scroll down for more questions▼

Answers (17)

vote up or down the answers
↑
2
↓
gothicskittlescupcake
Jeff,but I'm not a crazy fangirl.
reply
on December 15, 2014
Report
↑
2
↓
Masubii_Chan
S
L
E
N
D
Y
! See More▼
reply
on November 06, 2014
Report
↑
2
↓
LunaWolf279
JEFF THE KILLER !!! OR EJ ! OR LJ GAH CAT CHOSE!
reply
on November 06, 2014
Report
↑
1
↓
RaLLiCrossoverH2
Ticci Toby
He's awsome
reply
TicciToby335
I know right?
reply
on November 08, 2014
Report
on November 08, 2014
Report
↑
1
↓
J.Killa
Like who?...hm....
JEFF THE HOTTY FRICKIN KILLER!! xD
He's so damn hot,sexy,dangerous,aaaaand...
MINE!! hehe
reply
KylieTheKiller
Hey Jason!
Jason: ya?
Kill her please....
Jason: yepper doo *slices down*
reply
on August 03, 2017
Report
KylieTheKiller
Go to sleep, asshole.
reply
on August 03, 2017
Report
on November 06, 2014
Report
↑
1
↓
TicciToby335
Ticci toby
reply
on November 06, 2014
Report
↑
0
↓
Imsuperunnatural
Ben drowned and Lazari
reply
on June 15, 2021
Report
↑
0
↓
vampiro8250
um Idk if Toby Is Still A Creepypasta BUT Ma Fav Is Toby
reply
on January 27, 2021
Report
↑
0
↓
official_simp_for_Todoroki
ALL OF THEM OFC
reply
on October 18, 2020
Report
↑
0
↓
Travis.Phelps
jeff the killer
reply
Travis.Phelps
not a crazy fan girl
reply
on December 01, 2019
Report
on December 01, 2019
Report
↑
0
↓
Mina_Ashido
Ticci Toby!
reply
on May 08, 2019
Report
↑
0
↓
Laz_Proxy
Slenderman hes very nice but its a little annoying that he keeps on calling me a "CHILD"
reply
on May 07, 2019
Report
↑
0
↓
KylieTheKiller
Jeff is the hottest thang since sliced bread xd and I make the sliced bread hot by putting it in a toaster xd
reply
on August 03, 2017
Report
↑
0
↓
KylieTheKiller
Jeffy ? and then slender, then masky, and blah blah blah....
reply
on August 03, 2017
Report
↑
0
↓
Library_Guy
Don't Walk The Yellow Brick Road.
reply
on November 29, 2016
Report
↑
0
↓
WifeOfLaughingJack
I am gonna say Masky and Jeff, and yes, I'm a crazy fangirl! ^////^
reply
on November 28, 2016
Report
↑
0
↓
Lunacrafted
Idk but I do love ticci-Toby and Jeff<3
reply
on January 23, 2015
Report