Mistakes in Warrior Cats

Mistakes in Warrior Cats

So this is a list of mistakes (or things that puzzle me) that Erin Hunter did wrong! O.O I will probably get some things wrong, but this is what I think!

published on April 30156 reads 24 readers 15 not completed
Chapter 1.

Sandstorm's 'Trip' to the Moonstone

Me: So, would you like to know about a mistake that Erin Hunter made?

You: Sure, but Warrior Cats is perfect, you know.

Me: Nothing's perfect... Not even this PERFECT book series!

You: Okay, continue...

Me: So, in book four, Rising Storm of series one, The Prophecies Begin, when Cloudpaw is stolen by twolegs and Ravenpaw alerted Fireheart, at the time clan deputy about this cat, Sandstorm came along with the two to help them find Cloudpaw. Well...

You: Yes?

Me: When the three cats pass through Windclan territory to get to where Ravenpaw said he saw Cloudpaw, Erin Hunter said that Sandstorm only went through Windclan once on her trip to the Moonstone...

You: So?

Me: In ANY of those first three books in the first series, did Erin Hunter say ANYTHING about ANYTHING about Sandstorm going to the Moonstone before becoming a
warrior?

You: Um, no...?

Me: Right! No!

You: Yes, go on...!

Me: And, when Fireheart fought in a battle alongside Sandpaw and Dustpaw, he suddenly meowed, 'These two fought like warriors' and told Bluestar it was time for them to become... Well, warriors. And nothing said in any of those books something like 'Sandpaw and Dustpaw followed Bluestar and so-and-so for there first journey to accompany the two warriors to the Moonstone'. No! Nothing said ANYTHING of that sort at ALL!

You: O.O

Me: And it IS the warrior code to take an apprentice at at least one journey to the Moonstone.
Join Qfeast to read the entire story!
Sign In. It is absolutely free!
3.7
Please Rate:
3.7 out of 5 from 3 users
Add story to favorites
▼Scroll down for more stories

Comments (15)

SilverMoonthepotato
Another mistake is Rowanclaw changed their gender from female to male 0-0
reply
Dawnstar
Yup. Weird...
reply
Report
on June 17
Report
on June 15
SmolBeanie696
Cannibalistic Cloudpaw.
reply
Dawnstar
XD
reply
Report
on May 04
Report
on May 04
Dei_Dei
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=9fHp03ZiKzE
Bahaha there's so much in there!! xD
reply
Dawnstar
WOAH
reply
Report
on May 02
Report
on May 01
Dawnstar
Is there such thing as turning off commenting...???
reply
SmolBeanie696
Yes.
reply
Dawnstar
Okay.
reply
Report
on May 25
Report
on May 02
Report
on May 01
SmolBeanie696
I should tell "You" that Thistleclaw would only kill cats if he became leader. That's what it said in Bluestar's Prophecy.
reply
Report
on May 01
SoulOfTheWolves_Inactive
Firestar one is true firestar is a mary sue
reply
Report
on May 01
SmolBeanie696
OMFG YOU ARE SO RIGHT ABOUT PERFECTION AND FIRESTAR AND DHSJDUSHSMKSKSKSJJSHD!
reply
Dawnstar
Thanks for favoriting! ^^
reply
Report
on May 01
Dawnstar
Ikr? I understand that the main character should be... The main character, but, I mean, Sandstorm would probably the 'perfect' one if SHE were the main character! It's just... I don't know. It kind of annoys me a little. BUT I STILL LOVE WARRIOR CATS!!! (The mistakes still annoys me though)
reply
SmolBeanie696
Yeah, I totally get it.
reply
Report
on May 01
Report
on May 01
Report
on May 01