Who is the best creepy pasta?

My fav is Eyeless Jack.

Be the first to add this question to starred list!
▼Scroll down for more questions▼

Answers (16)

vote up or down the answers
↑
1
↓
Kittenlo
BEN IS BEST
reply
on April 12, 2014
Report
↑
1
↓
Kittenlo
Ben
reply
on April 12, 2014
Report
↑
1
↓
Cristallite
Jeff is best
reply
on April 06, 2014
Report
↑
0
↓
Lil_Phoenix
my bf Ticci Toby
reply
on September 23, 2020
Report
↑
0
↓
EyelessEmilyKiller
E.J *gives him a kidney and I eat mine*
reply
on June 11, 2017
Report
↑
0
↓
Quake
Slenderman will be my top favorite forever
reply
on August 29, 2015
Report
↑
0
↓
breann.west.5
Ben is love. Ben is LIFE!!!
reply
on July 20, 2015
Report
↑
0
↓
The_last_CoD_Ghost
1.Sonic.exe
2.tails doll
3.slender man
reply
on April 03, 2015
Report
↑
0
↓
AnimePup
Ben Drowned!!!
reply
on September 28, 2014
Report
↑
0
↓
Ravenclaw3243
EJ! *Hands over kidney*
EJ: Thanks
Me: No problem
reply
on July 31, 2014
Report
↑
0
↓
Therake
ME!
reply
on May 03, 2014
Report
↑
0
↓
Kittenlo
nope
reply
on April 12, 2014
Report
↑
0
↓
dark_century
no Jeff is the best !!!!!! every creepy pasta besides Jeff : *cries* Jeff: <3
reply
on April 01, 2014
Report
↑
0
↓
Stars_In_The_Sky
BEN!!!!!!!!
reply
Stars_In_The_Sky
:)
reply
on March 16, 2014
Report
Noescaping
Ben is my second fav.
reply
on March 16, 2014
Report
on March 16, 2014
Report
↑
0
↓
Therightofthedead
t my favorite is slenderman.
reply
on March 16, 2014
Report
↑
0
↓
kittey
Jeff the Killer or The Rake... I cant decide
reply
on March 16, 2014
Report