Which creepypasta is scariest? (1)

Jeff
27.3%
3 votes
Ben
0%
0 votes
Slender
9.1%
1 vote
Clockwork
0%
0 votes
Kate
0%
0 votes
Smile Dog
9.1%
1 vote
Ticci Toby
0%
0 votes
Hoodie
0%
0 votes
Masky
0%
0 votes
EJ
0%
0 votes
LJ
9.1%
1 vote
Other
45.5%
5 votes
Be the first to add this poll to starred list!
▼Scroll down for more polls

Comments (10)

Gangnamgreen
Well I think bloody Mary is pretty scary mostly because I did it and that was my paranormal ing that happened to me but I also think that sally is pretty scary too
reply
Creepypasta_Jayden
Report
on September 26, 2016
Report
on September 25, 2016
SugarPlum
Hnmhn none
I'm sorry
reply
Report
on May 26, 2016
Pingu
all those animal jam creepypastas made by 9 year olds
reply
Report
on May 26, 2016
Dead_Misfortune
Lazari
reply
Dead_Misfortune
She's like a little demon girl of some kind. Only 8 years old
reply
Report
on May 26, 2016
Creepypasta_Jayden
Who is that?
reply
Report
on May 26, 2016
Report
on May 26, 2016
WaitForIt
None of them are scary. More of depressing
reply
Creepypasta_Jayden
Well, I think that Jeff is pretty effing scary
reply
WaitForIt
Well, honestly, it's more of sad. He was beaten up as a kid and then ended up having his brother in jail for taking the blame, and ended up beaten up once more, only to go mentally unstable from so much at once.
reply
Report
on May 26, 2016
Report
on May 26, 2016
Report
on May 26, 2016